Imagine that

There is an air of deep disquiet about Leonora Carrington’s 1969 painting Operation Wednesday, which is offered in The Mind’s Eye sale at Bonhams in March. Two ghostly veiled figures, dressed in white and so thinly painted as to appear transparent, flank a third, draped in black and also see-through – the medium is tempera on board – with a lurid crimson socket, reminiscent of a small pomegranate, where one eye might have been. Above them, a vulture hovers, while a second avian harbinger of death looks on. A skeleton writes with a quill dipped in the blood of a dead pigeon. There’s a butterfly too, with eyes in its wings. And a chimerical, doleful creature seems to have emerged from the central figure’s skirt. The floor is a grid on which symbols, formulae and mirror-written words are inscribed. It’s a sinister scene. Are they alchemists? Or torturers?
Or surgeons, as implied by the painting’s dedicatee, Dr Fernando Ortiz Monasterio? The evidence points to the latter. At the bottom is an inscription in Spanish. Translating as “October 2, 1968… don’t forget Tlatelolco… the three cultures”, it refers to the Tlatelolco Massacre on the Plaza de las Tres Culturas in Mexico City, where, ten days before the start of the 1968 Olympic Games, which the city was hosting, the Mexican Armed Forces opened fire on students protesting against human rights violations and government abuses. Hundreds were slaughtered, thousands injured. Dr Monasterio was not just an orator, but an outstanding cranio-facial surgeon, who ministered to the maimed. Morbid though the imagery is, the painting is less a requiem for the dead, than a tribute to the living.
By then, Carrington had been resident in the city for more than 25 years. Her sons were activists. Horrified by what had happened and aware they were all under surveillance, they left for the US. She painted Operation Wednesday the following year – a work that reflects many aspects of an extraordinary life.

Leonora Carrington, The Temptation of St Anthony, 1947
Leonora Carrington, The Temptation of St Anthony, 1947

Leonora Carrington, The Giantess of the Egg, c. 1947
Leonora Carrington, The Giantess of the Egg, c. 1947
The daughter of a wealthy textile magnate and his Irish wife, Carrington was born in 1917, near Chorley, Lancashire, in the north of England. As her biographer Dawn Adès has written, it was “a social world of arcane rituals, subtle hierarchies, animal sacrifice [there was a lot of fox hunting] and festering tradition”.
As a child, she revelled in the Celtic myths and legends her mother and Irish nanny used to tell her, but her reaction to almost everything else was to rebel. Her governesses found her ungovernable and several schools expelled her, though, at 17, she was unwillingly presented to George V at Buckingham Palace. (An accomplished writer of prose every bit as hallucinatory as her painting, she subsequently published a short story entitled ‘The Debutante’.) Art was her calling, though, and eventually her parents let her study, first in Florence (where the works of Arcimboldo and Uccello made a particular impression), then at the Chelsea School of Art and with the Cubist painter Amédée Ozenfant.
The defining moment of her youth came, however, one evening in 1937, when a fellow student, Ursula Blackwell, wife of the architect Ernő Goldfinger, invited her to dinner with German Surrealist artist Max Ernst. The bottle of beer that Carrington had just opened overflowed with foam, and Ernst reached to staunch it with his thumb. She already knew and revered his work. “You know when something really touches you, it feels like burning,” she wrote. It was a coup de foudre. She was not quite 20; he was 46 and already on his second, of four, marriages, but off she went to Cornwall with him, to a house party that included Eileen Agar, Paul Éluard, Lee Miller and Man Ray. And when he finally returned to Paris, she followed him and “stayed and stayed” at his apartment on the rue Jacob, not far from Picasso’s house, where they mixed with the likes of Jean Arp, André Breton and Yves Tanguy.
As a couple “they looked exactly like Nell and her grandfather in The Old Curiosity Shop”, recalled Peggy Guggenheim in her 1946 autobiography Out of This Century. She had gone to buy a painting of Ernst’s but came away instead with one of Carrington’s, The Horses of Lord Candlestick, the name Carrington gave her father, who became so incensed by her relationship with Ernst that he tried to have him arrested on grounds of exhibiting pornography. And later she bought – and, crucially, kept – Oink (They Shall Behold Thine Eyes) (1959), which remains in her collection in Venice to this day.
Struck both by her talent and her beauty, Guggenheim wrote that Carrington was “very good and full of imagination. Her skin was like alabaster, and her hair was rich in its black waviness. She had enormous, mad, dark eyes, with thick black brows and a tip-tilted nose. Her figure was lovely, but she always dressed badly on purpose” – an affectation, she noted with hindsight, “connected with her madness”. For in 1940, Carrington had been incarcerated on grounds of “incurable insanity”.
When World War II broke out, Ernst and Carrington were living in a cottage in the Ardèche, the better to distance themselves from his wife. Ernst was imprisoned, first as an enemy alien by the French, then by the Nazis for painting degenerate art. Carrington fled to Spain, where the “anguish that accumulated in me” overcame her. She records, in her harrowing memoir Down Below, the experience of her mind “drifting into fiction”.
Admitted to a sanatorium in Santander, she was strapped to a bed and treated with pentylenetetrazol, which induced terrifying seizures. But, by 1941, she had recovered sufficiently to make her way to Lisbon, accompanied by her nanny, who had been sent to rescue her, crossing the Bay of Biscay, improbably, by submarine, with instructions to put her on a ship to South Africa.

Leonora Carrington, Untitled, c. 1949-50
Leonora Carrington, Untitled, c. 1949-50

A world of her own: Leonora Carrington in her studio
A world of her own: Leonora Carrington in her studio
Meanwhile Guggenheim had secured Ernst’s release, and they too arrived in Lisbon, awaiting a Pan Am Clipper flight to New York. “I felt a dagger go through my heart,” Guggenheim wrote, when Ernst told her he had run into Carrington by chance. But – as another of her biographers, Joanna Moorhead, puts it – their affair “was not reignited”. Instead, Ernst married Guggenheim, who later admitted that even Breton “confirmed my opinion that [Leonora] was the only woman Max had ever loved”.
Carrington had no plans to go to Africa, preferring the sound of America. A Mexican diplomat, the poet Renato Leduc, to whom Picasso had introduced her in Paris, had been posted to Portugal, so she presented herself at the Mexican embassy. And there, reader, she married him. They sailed to New York and, in 1943, drove to Mexico.
That summer Guggenheim’s New York gallery, Art of This Century, included a Carrington painting in the legendary Exhibition by 31 Women, a show suggested by Marcel Duchamp and co-curated by Ernst and Breton, featuring female Surrealists such as Leonor Fini, Meret Oppenheim and Dorothea Tanning, as well as Frida Kahlo and, more surprisingly, Gypsy Rose Lee. Carrington, she said, was already painting in “the best Surrealist manner”, full of “animals and birds rather resembling Bosch’s”.
But Mexico opened Carrington’s eyes to another world entirely. Everything was “exciting and utterly strange, even the trees”, she recalled. She was fascinated by “the character of the people, their contact with the dead, the variety of food, plants, animals and landscape”. Its mythology intrigued her, too: hence perhaps the most important painting she made in Mexico, The Magical World of the Maya (1964), 4.5m long and fantastical even by her own standards. Commissioned by the National Museum of Anthropology and History for its opening, it was evidence of her importance to her adopted country. She was less entranced by her husband, and having fallen in with a group of artists, left him for Emeric Weisz (‘Chiki’), a Hungarian photographer who had managed Robert Capa’s darkroom in the Spanish Civil War. Though she continued to have affairs, not least with the Nobel laureate Octavio Paz, their marriage lasted till his death, aged 97, in 2007. She outlived him by four years.
Among this circle was the female Spanish Surrealist painter Remedios Varo, with whom Carrington used to visit the Mercado de Sonora or ‘witchcraft market’ – the occult was another enduring theme in her work. As Margaret Hooks, author of Surreal Lovers: Eight Women Integral to the Life of Max Ernst, wrote, “Natural healers and savants introduced them to alchemical experiments that they later practised in their kitchens”, an activity that surely has some bearing on Operation Wednesday.
But those who knew Carrington learnt never to ask her to decipher her work (nor to ask about her lovers). “Nothing to explain,” she’d bark. Rather her paintings – which Luis Buñuel praised for their ability to “liberate us from the miserable reality of our days” – were challenges to the imagination. In the end, her alchemy was less about preparing potions in her kitchen than in playing with perceptions of the world.
Claire Wrathall writes for the Telegraph and the Financial Times.
We are proud to announce a new Surrealist Sale for 2021; The Mind’s Eye. This cross-disciplinary sale will bring together fresh-to-the-market paintings, unique works on paper, sculpture, design, photography and books encompassing the arc of the Surrealist narrative.
Please contact us to consign to the inaugural auction.
surrealism@bonhams.com
